After a few classes, I have begun to look more closely at classroom dynamics here. First off, there seems to be an element of intimidation and fear between students and professors/lecturers. Students rarely, if ever ask questions or supply answers. Whenever a professor tries to engage the class, it usually fails because nobody speaks up. Discussion is almost non apparent especially when the professor doesn’t call on people and force them to answer.
Having ‘taught’ a class at Mlimani, I can start to understand the conditions that have made class based on discussion and student teacher interaction almost impossible. The teachers are so authoritarian and unforgiving, that if a student were to ever volunteer an answer and then get it wrong, the teacher would discipline them. The only time students ever gave answers were when they were forced to.
Another observation I have made is that all students try to write the notes from the lecture in full, aiming to write down exactly what the professor is saying, word for word. This too, I feel, goes right back to how the education system works, starting from primary school where the teacher writes down exactly what they want the children to write down. The often come around to make sure that what the students have written is exactly what is on the board, nothing more and nothing less. Now at university, when the professor doesn’t usually write down anything on the blackboard, I feel like the students think that they need to write down everything the professor is saying. There seems to be little room left over for any thinking done by themselves.
So when it comes time to study for a test, all they will have is what the professor has said, which can sometimes (I speak from experience) be the most bias and inaccurate answer ever given. So all of this gets memorized as is, regurgitated on a test and never really questioned. Now, no matter how accurate the information is, there is a group of anywhere from 50-500 students who know have the same mindsets and information as the teacher. The way information is passed on, or not passed on, here is sad.
Monday, November 10, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
I think that here you've hit the nail on the head. THIS is what it means to me when people say that America is free. We have had such blessings and opportunities to learn things - not just the things that our teachers had a chance to learn, but things that people all over the world are discovering and learning. Means of communication are different, the ability, both personally and culturally, to question authoritative voices is so incredible different. Have you had the opportunity to talk to any students about this? I think that a comparison of teaching habits, simply from an observers perspective (meaning outside of someone who is getting a degree in teaching, like Wendy) would be so interesting. How does a professor teach in the US, either at a community like Luther or at, say, your high school? Are they similar ways as the experience of Mandy, at a large uni? Or the Eriks, at a Swedish uni? If you are still seeking a project, this could be an idea - simply observing and talking to people about how they are taught, how they are taught to study, how their education experience has shaped them today? Your writing provokes so many questions in my mind - I wish I was there to help find the answers!!
Post a Comment